Actual cash value vs replacement cost

Two ways a policy can pay for what you lost. The difference is wear.

  • Checked November 17, 2026
  • 4 sources
On this page
  1. The difference in one example
  2. How to tell which one you have
  3. Why the first check can be low
  4. What some states say
  5. Questions
  6. Where this comes from

The short answer

Actual cash value is what it costs to replace an item new, minus wear for its age and condition. Replacement cost is what it costs to buy the same kind of item new, with no wear taken off. A replacement cost policy often pays the actual cash value first, then the rest after you replace the item.

The difference in one example

Actual cash valueReplacement cost
TV, 3 years old, costs $900 new$900 minus wear$900
If wear is 37.5% (3 of 8 years)$562.50$900
When it is paidUsually firstThe rest, often after you replace it

The 8-year life is only for the example. Insurers use their own tables.

How to tell which one you have

Look at your declarations page and the loss settlement part of your policy. The NAIC says that if the declarations page doesn't say replacement cost, the coverage is likely actual cash value. Ask your agent or insurer to confirm in writing.

Why the first check can be low

When the first payment is actual cash value, wear and your deductible come off. The part held back for wear is called recoverable depreciation when your policy lets you collect it later.

What some states say

California defines actual cash value in its insurance code. It is the cost to repair, rebuild or replace, minus a fair deduction for wear based on condition, or the policy limit if that is less. Many other states leave the method to the policy.

Questions

Is actual cash value the same as market value?
Not always. Some policies and states use market value, and others use replacement cost minus depreciation. Your policy and state law decide.
Can I get replacement cost if I don't replace the item?
Usually not the held back part. Many policies pay it only after you replace or repair. Check your policy and any time limit.
Does depreciation apply to labor?
It depends on your state and policy. Ask your insurer how they handled labor in your estimate.

Where this comes from

  1. NAIC, Post-Disaster Claims Guide
  2. Texas Department of Insurance, Home insurance guide
  3. California Department of Insurance, Residential insurance guide
  4. California Insurance Code section 2051

Facts checked . This is general information, not legal or insurance advice. See how we check facts or report a mistake.

Start your list free